Matt McAvoy Book Review

This is quite an unusual book to read, in that it is first-half background fact and second-half fictionalization of it, furthermore delivered in the format of a screenplay.  Justin Stamm makes no secret of the fact that it is his intention to serialize his television show one episode at a time, presumably as a marketing strategy to generate buzz and capitalize on his hard work.  I don’t know if this plan will work out for him – I hope it does – but from the reader’s point of view it perhaps does make for a slightly frustrating experience.  The fact that Stamm is undoubtedly a credible authority in the subject matter, with an intimate working knowledge of the mafia and its involvement in the entertainment industry mid-last century, makes for an incredibly enthralling read and premise; this therefore feels like a multi-pronged approach which doesn’t really make the best of any of the chosen formats.  The first half of the book feels a little concise, when there is undoubtedly epic potential in any factual book about the inner workings of the Mob, and it rather seems that the book’s primary objective is for Justin to present his screenplay; it is best for the reader to be aware of this – though, fair play to Justin, he is open about it.  Still, it doesn’t make it any less disappointing that I didn’t get to read more about Lansky and Jimmy Alo, which I think I would have enjoyed.  I wonder if Justin can be persuaded to expand this historical expose a little more; with the likes of Joe Kennedy and J. Edgar Hoover involved, it surely makes for a fascinating slice of American history.

As for the screenplay, it seems to be an entertaining one, though I wonder why Justin chose to serialize it on the page rather than hold out to get it on the screen – I suppose that is his business and he has his reasons.  It is enjoyable, though I say that personally as a reader who is experienced in reading plays, whereas many may not be.  I suppose, then, the biggest question raised by this book is, does a non-fiction/screenplay hybrid format work?  The answer to that, I would suggest, is yes it does, though as mentioned, I would rather see one or the other in a much more committed composition, rather than both in part.  I would also suggest that Justin has significantly limited his niche readership by opting for the format.  That said, I personally found it an interesting and enjoyable read which, honestly, left me hoping to read much more – of either part of the book – and it is definitely worth a look if you like Mob history and TV.